Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
1inStripes
If thats what you believe in then yes.
That's true. That's what I should do, but it's really not that easy. People look down at non-believers quite a bit around here, I hear it during class at MECC constantly. This is a pretty Christian area, it's everywhere...from them outside of Walmart, to the fair, to handing out pocket-bibles at the college. People look at you different when they find that out, like you're some terrible, evil person.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MikeJones
The school ok'd the game to and football is violent at times does that meen the school condones violence? I think folks just liek to find things to ***** about these day. We are gonna have tree huggers showing up saying they hear the trees cry when the paper rips as the teams run through them next.
Do you only read what you want to read?
This is not a new practice;
the separation of church and state dates back WAY before any football game.
I want you to use your brain to full potential right here;
You pay taxes, correct? How would you feel if your tax dollars went to a public school that was pro-Scientology? or pro-Muslim?
Would you be offended or upset? I guarantee it.
Now that's how I feel when I realize the taxes I pay go to schools that sanction Christian prayer.
When I have kids, I really want to raise them in this area, its safe, its clean, etc..
But the one worry I have is that the schools will not do my kid justice, because I won't be taking him to church.
And you say we are *****ing about this, no its YOU that is *****ing about this, the article clearly states that GC wont do it again, they recognize the problems with it.
Its YOUR kind that is all up in arms about this, even though the CONSTITUTION STRICTLY PROHIBITS THESE KINDS OF ACTIONS.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Biggin
You JUST said in your post that Christians' should be allowed, in this area, to practice their religion. Why shouldn't atheists?
Why do I have to be subjected to your prayers and such?
Let me ask you this; if I was leading a prayer somewhere, and I said God doesnt exist, people put faith in fairy tales, etc...would you be offended? I guarantee it.
Then why is it so wrong that I get offended by people just assuming everyone is Christian and agrees with praying and doing things the 'Christian' way?
When I go to a public school sporting event, I should NOT be made to sit and listen to a Christian prayer that is sanctioned by a school. That is saying 'THIS SCHOOL BELIEVES IN JESUS!"
How is that right in the least?
Would I be offended? No, and you know that. You and I have discussed religion numerous times and we both know how each feel about it. I don't think any less of you and you do not think less of me. I just fail to see how you are being forced to do anything. You can talk to the guy beside you, go buy a popcorn, or whatever. If you were leading a prayer one would assume the only being following you would be those who follow the same beliefs you have. I'm not very religious and will agree that religion has caused many wrongs throughout the world but it has also served a major purpose as well. Studies have shown that up to 86% of the people living in the Bible Belt, which I would put this area in, are of the Christian Faith. As I stated in one of my original posts in this thread, the Constitution states for the general welfare, how could you get much more general than 86%?
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Biggin
Do you only read what you want to read?
This is not a new practice;
the separation of church and state dates back WAY before any football game.
I want you to use your brain to full potential right here;
You pay taxes, correct? How would you feel if your tax dollars went to a public school that was pro-Scientology? or pro-Muslim?
Would you be offended or upset? I guarantee it.
Now that's how I feel when I realize the taxes I pay go to schools that sanction Christian prayer.
When I have kids, I really want to raise them in this area, its safe, its clean, etc..
But the one worry I have is that the schools will not do my kid justice, because I won't be taking him to church.
And you say we are *****ing about this, no its YOU that is *****ing about this, the article clearly states that GC wont do it again, they recognize the problems with it.
Its YOUR kind that is all up in arms about this, even though the CONSTITUTION STRICTLY PROHIBITS THESE KINDS OF ACTIONS.
Plenty of kids around here don't attend church btw. Taxes have gone to fund Muslim schools to. LOL my kind that is up at arms? The ACLU is not my kind. I think they are the ones they complained first threatening lawsuits or whatever.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pvfan
Would I be offended? No, and you know that. You and I have discussed religion numerous times and we both know how each feel about it. I don't think any less of you and you do not think less of me. I just fail to see how you are being forced to do anything. You can talk to the guy beside you, go buy a popcorn, or whatever. If you were leading a prayer one would assume the only being following you would be those who follow the same beliefs you have. I'm not very religious and will agree that religion has caused many wrongs throughout the world but it has also served a major purpose as well. Studies have shown that up to 86% of the people living in the Bible Belt, which I would put this area in, are of the Christian Faith. As I stated in one of my original posts in this thread, the Constitution states for the general welfare, how could you get much more general than 86%?
But the Constitution plainly states that there has to be a separation of church and state.
So just because of the area we live in is dominated by Christianity, we should disregard the Sep. Church & State because it is 86% Christian?
What about the other 14%? Does the Constitution not also state we are all entitled to the rights of religious (or non-religious) freedom? Why should the other 14% have to live by the moral code subjected by the 86%?
That goes against everything our country stands for;
We are a land of freedom, the land of the free.
The Bill of Rights has been determined to say that your rights end at my rights, correct? Then your right to religious freedom only extends as far as mine does, correct?
So why should I be subjected to your religion?
But this isn't about me, or you, or any particular person
This is about Schools sanctioning Christian prayer, and I know you feel that is unconstitutional. So why are you fighting me so hard on this?
You know that it is highly illegal and immoral for tax funded schools to allow one religion to be the religion of the school.
There is a reason for moments of silence, why do most Christians hate that?
Because they want it to be a Christian prayer.
A moment of silence would solve all these issues; why is that not the obvious answer?
Because of this area's religious connotations. Apparently, a moment of silence is wrong,but a Christian prayer is right.
And you, I know you, and I know you know that prayers in schools is illegal and immoral.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MikeJones
Plenty of kids around here don't attend church btw. Taxes have gone to fund Muslim schools to. LOL my kind that is up at arms? The ACLU is not my kind. I think they are the ones they complained first threatening lawsuits or whatever.
You are not correct. Taxes do not go to fund public Muslim schools, thats a conflict of interest and totally against the Constitution.
No, the ACLU send a memo, GC agreed, the issue was over. But its the Christians in this thread that are so against getting rid of denominational prayer before football games, even though its a blatant slap in the face of the Separation of Church and State.
Why will you not address th Sep. of Church and State? Is it because you realize I am right, and dont want to admit it, or are you not familiar with the statute?
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Prayer in school is not illegal or immoral.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Biggin
But the Constitution plainly states that there has to be a separation of church and state.
So just because of the area we live in is dominated by Christianity, we should disregard the Sep. Church & State because it is 86% Christian?
What about the other 14%? Does the Constitution not also state we are all entitled to the rights of religious (or non-religious) freedom? Why should the other 14% have to live by the moral code subjected by the 86%?
That goes against everything our country stands for;
We are a land of freedom, the land of the free.
The Bill of Rights has been determined to say that your rights end at my rights, correct? Then your right to religious freedom only extends as far as mine does, correct?
So why should I be subjected to your religion?
But this isn't about me, or you, or any particular person
This is about Schools sanctioning Christian prayer, and I know you feel that is unconstitutional. So why are you fighting me so hard on this?
You know that it is highly illegal and immoral for tax funded schools to allow one religion to be the religion of the school.
There is a reason for moments of silence, why do most Christians hate that?
Because they want it to be a Christian prayer.
A moment of silence would solve all these issues; why is that not the obvious answer?
Because of this area's religious connotations. Apparently, a moment of silence is wrong,but a Christian prayer is right.
And you, I know you, and I know you know that prayers in schools is illegal and immoral.
By that theory you are totally against the polices California have in place that circumvent federal drug law?
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
1inStripes
Prayer in school is not illegal or immoral.
Nope, not at all.
But you know what I meant stripes, cmon man.
Prayer led by a teacher in school is illegal, when its done during class time.
Engel v. Vitale, U.S. Supreme Court Case Summary & Oral Argument
This is a link to the court case that sets the precedent that no school can allow prayers that are led in situations like that, where the school can be viewed as having a religious bias, such as including a Christian prayer in the opening proceedings of a ballgame.
Re: ACLU after Gate City High School
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pvfan
By that theory you are totally against the polices California have in place that circumvent federal drug law?
How does that have any bearing on what we are discussing?
I feel that all anti-drug laws are un-constitutional; life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness is directly given to me, and all other Americans. So prohibiting what I do to my body is un-constitutional, but that has zero to do with school-sanctioned prayer.